Don W.'s Top Ten List
The first 2 are definitely my 2 favs, but after that they are in no specific order :-) I looked through the list of games played on the website and this is all I could come up with. Unfortunately I haven't played most of the games on that list, and many others I've forgotten the names of, plus there are some I hear rave reviews about that I would really like to play, like Settlers of Catan and Carlos Magnus.
1. Settlers of Catan
2. Citadels
3. Condottiere
4. Bang!
5. Werewolf
6. Torres
7. Mississippi Queen
8. Labyrinth
9. Carcassonne - The one where you build a map with tiles and make castles and farms and stuff and you only get credit if the castle if it's completely built???
10. Liars Dice